A Comparison of the Similarities and Differences in the Conceptions of the Second Treatise of Government by John Locke and the Declaration of Independence

Updated August 1, 2022

Download Paper

File format: .pdf, .doc, available for editing

A Comparison of the Similarities and Differences in the Conceptions of the Second Treatise of Government by John Locke and the Declaration of Independence essay

Get help to write your own 100% unique essay

Get custom paper

78 writers are online and ready to chat

This essay has been submitted to us by a student. This is not an example of the work written by our writers.

The founding fathers used the work of John Locke’s Second Treatise of Government as a framework for the Declaration of Independence. The similarities are mainly notable in the claims against the King, but can also be found in the introduction of the letter. In the introduction, Locke’s concept of the state of nature is evident, while the influence of Locke’s ideals on political power and the function of government can be seen in the arguments presented in the Declaration. The most significant differences between the two documents is that the Declaration lacks some of the extreme views that Locke takes in his discussion on the state of war. Besides this, it is clear that the Declaration of Independence was built on Locke’s concepts of government. John Locke’s conception of the state of nature heavily influenced the writing of the Declaration. He devotes the second chapter of the Second Treatise of Government to discussing the state he believes men are naturally in and the rights they deserve. In chapter two, he presents the idea that men are created as equals when he says, “because it is simply obvious that creatures of the same species and status, all born to the same advantages of nature and to use of the same abilities, should also be equal” (Locke 3). This quote has such an influence on the Declaration because through stating the equality of men is obvious, Locke has made it indisputable.

The founding fathers desired a strong, indisputable statement for addressing the King, so they took inspiration from the passage when writing the famous line, “We hold these truths to be self evident, that all men are created equal” (Declaration). This line not only delivers a powerful message, but sets up the ideals that not only drive the rest of the letter and become a major part in shaping the new United States of America. The arguments made by Locke are often used to support the Declaration’s claims against the King. Beginning with the very first claim, Locke’s definition of political power is referenced. He defines political power as the right to make, regulate and enforce laws, highlighting that political power is only meant to be used for the public good. The first claim uses this definition to support that King George III has overstepped his power as the authors state that “He has refused his Assent to Laws, the most wholesome and necessary for the public good” (Declaration). This is in reference to the King vetoing laws that the colonies made which would improve their societies. Following the claim, the founding fathers give further support to it through examples of how the laws made by the King have harmed the colonies. These arguments lead into the claims which state the importance of consent when dealing with government. A couple of the ideals on government that Locke expresses are the significances of the consent of the governed and the problems with monarchy. He ends his chapter on the state of nature by highlighting how consent is required by the people; as he says, “and I also affirm that all men are naturally in the state of nature, and remain so until they consent to make themselves members of some political society” (Locke 7).

In the Declaration, the authors emphasize how the people of the colonies have not consented to the acts of the King, further supporting how he has abused his political power. This is specifically noted in the claim that the King has kept troops in the colonies against their will. Locke would attribute this abuse of power to the problems created when one man controls the government of many. The claims provided in the Declaration exemplify the problems that Locke raises about such monarchies as it explicitly says, “He has made judges dependent on his will alone” (Declaration). Government with a single man in charge is subject to the bias and flaws of that single man, thus leading to the unfair and tyrannical rule of King George III over the colonies. The Declaration of Independence serves as the colonies’ consent to succeed from the King’s rule and enter a new political society with ideals informed by Locke’s work. Despite many similarities between the Second Treatise of Government and the Declaration of Independence, there are a few differences between the two documents. One of these are the rights of men, which are “Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness” in the Declaration (Declaration). The difference here is very subtle as Locke states the rights of man in the state of nature are “his life, health, liberty, or possessions” (Locke 4).

Though the distinction between happiness and possessions seems insignificant, it highlights the difference in values between Locke and the other authors of the Declaration. Locke puts stress on how property and wealth are the most valuable things one can gain. The authors of the Declaration did not share this ideal and broaden it to the pursuit of happiness to accommodate for a wider range of beliefs. This take on the rights of man would later influence the formation of the United States government, specifically with the Bill of Rights of the US Constitution. The second and more notable difference is that the Declaration lacks some of the extreme ideals that Locke expresses in his work. Within his chapter on the state of war, Locke discusses the punishments man has the right to enforce on others for violating the laws of nature. Several of these can be viewed as extreme. For example, his justifies that the penalty for theft is death when he says, “This makes it lawful for me to kill a thief who hasn’t done me any harm or declared any plan against my life, other than using force to get me in his power so as to take away my money or whatever else he wants” (Locke 8). As examined previously, King George III has infringed upon many of the laws of nature and therefore the founding fathers had every right to demand the death of the King according to Locke’s ideals. No such demand is in the Declaration though due to the political impact that could have caused.

Such a demand could have created an even greater amount of uproar from those loyal to the King and could have lost some of the support for their cause. Other than the political influence it may have caused, the founding fathers do not demand his death in order to rise above King George III’s tyrannical rule. This departure from Locke’s influence elevates the Declaration of Independence by setting up the new forming government of the United States as more righteous than the rule of the King. The Second Treatise of Government had a clear influence on the authors of the Declaration of Independence. Locke’s chapter on the state of nature inspired several points in the Declaration, including its introduction and many of the claims made against the King. The founding fathers used Locke’s work to support their arguments that King George III was unfit to rule them and set up the preliminary values of the new United States. Overall, there are a multitude of similarities between the two documents, but there are a couple of differences. Both of these differences stem from Locke’s discussion of the state of war as the Declaration does not go to the same extend as this state. Despite these few variances, the Declaration of Independence makes it clear the influential role John Locke played on the formation of government in the United States of America.

A Comparison of the Similarities and Differences in the Conceptions of the Second Treatise of Government by John Locke and the Declaration of Independence essay

Remember. This is just a sample

You can get your custom paper from our expert writers

Get custom paper

A Comparison of the Similarities and Differences in the Conceptions of the Second Treatise of Government by John Locke and the Declaration of Independence. (2022, Aug 01). Retrieved from https://samploon.com/a-comparison-of-the-similarities-and-differences-in-the-conceptions-of-the-second-treatise-of-government-by-john-locke-and-the-declaration-of-independence/

We use cookies to give you the best experience possible. By continuing we’ll assume you’re on board with our cookie policy

I'm Peter!

Would you like to get a custom essay? How about receiving a customized one?

Check it out